This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Rebuilding the time and cost position on a complex water project


Client
Water-sector contractor
Service
Claims
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Approx. £24m original target cost
Sector
Water infrastructure

We supported a water-sector contractor facing substantial cost growth and delay on an existing-asset upgrade. The original target cost was approximately £24 million. We developed a staged recovery strategy, then worked with the technical, planning, commercial and legal teams to explain the events behind the changing programme and cost position in section-specific submissions.

Background

The immediate exposure involved potential delay damages alongside the effect of the contract’s pain-and-gain mechanism. The works were divided into distinct sections, each involving technical and operational interfaces with an existing asset.

The client needed to understand the reasons for the forecast deterioration and present a position that could be examined commercially. A single project-wide overspend did not explain which party carried a particular risk or how a specific change affected completion.

Our approach

We began with a commercial recovery plan that distinguished the imminent delay-damages exposure from the target-cost adjustments needed to address scope and other cost changes. The work was sequenced by section, allowing the team to focus its evidence and resources while continuing to deliver the project.

Multi-disciplinary workshops reconstructed the design and construction history. We brought together people with current and historic knowledge to compare what had been planned with what had occurred, identify the relevant events and locate the supporting records.

The contractual review examined the original specification, retained risks and subsequent requirements. On one section, this included the information available about physical model testing, structural loading and access to shared lifting equipment. The submission connected those matters with the additional requirements subsequently placed on the contractor.

The technical detail was important. Changes emerging from hydraulic model validation affected pipe geometry, pump arrangements, support frames and the civil works beneath them. The narrative traced that sequence so that a change to a technical requirement could be understood through to its effect on design and construction.

Other events involved obstructions, lifting-equipment breakdowns and additional structural support. We separated their factual histories and assessed their programme effects against the relevant activities, with the time and cost basis set out under the corresponding event.

The loss analysis reconciled tender allowances with forecast costs, distinguishing the effect of rates, resources, periods, quantities and additional scope. Time-related preliminaries and further target-cost items were considered alongside the delay work, with detailed appendices supporting the submission.

One section submission sought approximately 390 days and £4.3 million of target-cost adjustments across the identified events. Those figures represented the position advanced for that section, rather than a project-wide award or a sum shown to have been recovered.

The reports were structured for negotiation: the event, contractual basis, effect and valuation could be considered individually. This gave the senior teams a practical way to discuss the differences without requiring every technical issue to be resolved in one conversation.

Outcome

The established client record reports that the purchaser acknowledged responsibility for part of the delays and increased costs, allowing executive negotiations to open. The section-based reports provided the foundation for those discussions.

Our contribution was to connect a complex technical history with the programme and financial consequences, giving the client a substantiated position and a more controlled route for progressing the account.

Back to projects