
Turning a difficult project into practical commercial lessons
- Client
- MEP contractor
- Service
- Advisory
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Approx. £30m subcontract
- Sector
- Defence
We supported an MEP contractor undertaking an independent review of a major defence project that had materially underperformed. Working with its audit and assurance team, we combined interviews with financial and contractual analysis to explain how the position had developed. The work produced five principal lessons, supported by detailed findings and recommendations for the business.
Background
The board needed confidence that the reasons for the project’s financial loss had been understood and that appropriate preventative measures could be tested. An end-of-project account alone would not explain how tender assumptions, design decisions, delivery arrangements and reported forecasts had interacted over time.
The review needed to be sufficiently detailed for the senior team to examine the findings, while presenting the board with a concise set of conclusions and actions.
Our approach
We worked alongside the audit and assurance team, combining its knowledge of the organisation’s governance with our experience of project delivery and commercial management. Regular progress meetings and agreed methods of sharing information kept the review focused as the evidence developed.
Interviews covered people involved from work winning and tendering through pre-construction, delivery and completion. We compared accounts of the same issue rather than relying on one retrospective explanation, and tested those accounts against the available records.
The financial work reconstructed performance over time from files with different structures and naming conventions. We compared project cost-value reporting with business-unit reviews and examined how changes in forecast were presented at different levels of the organisation. This helped identify where an apparent movement required a clearer explanation.
We also followed the contract history. Significant amendments, changes to delivery strategy and decisions to progress work ahead of full design approval needed to be considered against the obligations and risks being assumed. The review connected those decisions with the governance and approval records available.
The five principal lessons addressed bid decisions, the continuing review of strategy, contract understanding, the approval of significant amendments and the transparency of project reporting. The recommendations were specific: balanced risk-and-opportunity assessments, defined review points, named decision owners and a recorded basis for changes to the forecast.
Supporting findings examined the practical delivery interfaces behind those themes, including design coordination, document control, resource planning and the involvement of technical assurance functions. This allowed the senior team to consider the systems that would help the desired behaviours occur on future work.
The reporting retained two levels of detail. The board received the principal lessons, while the wider findings gave senior leaders the evidence and reasoning needed to test whether existing controls already addressed each issue or whether further action was required.
Outcome
The review provided a structured explanation of the project’s commercial history and a practical set of recommendations for the business. Management could examine both the immediate lessons and the supporting decisions, records and reporting processes.
Our contribution was to turn a difficult project experience into evidence that could inform future governance and delivery, with a clear basis for assessing the measures intended to reduce the risk of recurrence.
Back to projects