This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Independently valuing a seven-figure termination account


Client
Employer, through its solicitors
Service
Expert Witness
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Approx. £8m construction contract
Sector
Residential construction

We provided independent quantum expert evidence for an employer responding to a termination-account claim of approximately £1 million. The residential construction contract was worth approximately £8 million. Within the adjudication timetable, we examined the value of completed work separately from the losses said to arise from termination, preparing reports and valuations that could be tested against the underlying records.

Background

The contractor’s employment had ended before the works were complete. Its termination account combined the valuation of work and variations with claims for lost profit, supply-chain termination costs and other losses.

Those elements required different valuation principles. An amount previously certified on an interim basis did not automatically establish the final value of work, and a subcontract order did not by itself demonstrate the loss caused by termination.

Our approach

We first reconciled the account submitted before the adjudication with the amount claimed in the referral. Differences in professional fees and supply-chain figures were identified so that the analysis addressed the claim actually before the adjudicator.

We retained the contractor’s account structure and placed our valuation alongside it. This made the comparison transparent: the parties and adjudicator could follow the same claim head through the original amount, the evidence and our assessment.

The completed-work review considered progress, the contract sum analysis, variations and materials. Particular attention was given to provisional sums, where the final valuation needed to distinguish the original allowance from the value of the work instructed. This avoided allowing percentage-based interim treatment to obscure the final assessment.

The termination-cost review addressed the claimed loss of profit and supply-chain liabilities separately. We considered whether a cost followed from termination, the evidence of a likely liability and the appropriate basis of valuation. The distinction between overheads and profit was examined rather than treating a combined contractual fee as pure profit.

We also reviewed the evidence supporting individual construction items. For scaffolding, for example, we analysed the payment information and explained the assessed amount by reference to the underlying record. The adjudicator expressly accepted that analysis in the decision.

The initial report and valuation were prepared in ten days, followed by further evidence for the rejoinder over four days. We also attended the adjudicator’s meetings to explain the calculations, address questions and identify the evidence supporting our opinions.

Our role remained that of an independent expert. The report stated the assumptions and information on which each opinion depended, allowing particular items to be examined without requiring the whole account to be accepted as one position.

Outcome

The adjudicator ordered a payment of approximately £600,000, compared with the contractor’s claim of approximately £1 million. The decision reached its own valuation, accepting parts of our analysis within that assessment.

The expert reports gave the legal team a detailed, reasoned basis for addressing the termination account under a demanding timetable, with the individual valuation issues and supporting evidence made accessible to the adjudicator.

Back to projects