This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Testing an interim valuation against the work actually performed


Client
Developer, through its solicitors
Service
Expert Witness
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Approx. £430,000 payment examined
Sector
Student residential

We provided independent quantum expert evidence for a developer considering a claim concerning an interim payment assessment. Approximately £430,000 had been paid before the main contractor entered administration. We reconstructed the value of the work from the contract and available progress evidence, then compared that assessment with the quantity surveyor’s payment notice.

Background

Following the contractor’s administration, the developer was concerned that the amount paid did not reflect the work completed. Recovery from the contractor appeared unlikely, so the professional quantity surveyor’s assessment and performance required examination.

The instruction covered both valuation and the reasonableness of the payment notice. The report therefore needed to explain the value of the work independently before considering how the certified amount had been reached.

Our approach

We reviewed the construction contract, the consultant’s appointment, payment applications and notices, the termination information and a separately commissioned progress report. The contractual documents established the valuation framework, while the progress evidence showed the work available to be valued.

The physical record described limited site preparation, reduced-level excavation and a piling mat, with some concrete clearance still outstanding. We worked through those elements individually rather than applying a broad percentage to the overall construction budget.

Where a measured quantity was unavailable, we explained how it had been derived. For the piling mat, the report used photographs and identifiable fence-panel dimensions to estimate the occupied area, deducted an area where the mat was absent, and stated the assumptions used for material and depth. The calculation remained conditional on further evidence.

We considered professional fees, preliminaries, overheads and profit, contingency and variations separately. A design allowance in an application did not establish that design work had been produced, and the passage of time did not establish a proportionate value of preliminaries. Each heading was examined against the information available.

The resulting valuation was then placed alongside the payment notice. This exposed the differences between the work supported by the progress evidence and the amounts certified for site work, design and preliminaries. Retention was shown separately so that the comparison addressed both the gross valuation and the amount payable.

We also considered the quantity surveyor’s appointment and the services expected in connection with procurement, the contractor’s financial position and interim assessments. The report distinguished the expert opinion on professional performance from matters that would ultimately require legal determination.

The final report was dated approximately three weeks after instruction. It set out the calculations, supporting documents and circumstances in which further evidence could alter the opinion, giving the legal team a reasoned basis for considering the proposed claim.

Outcome

Our opinion identified an overpayment of approximately £410,000 against the payment examined. This was an expert assessment of the evidence, with its assumptions made explicit; it was not a court award or a sum shown to have been recovered.

The report provided the developer and its solicitors with an independent valuation and a structured explanation of the differences, supporting discussions about the professional services and the resulting financial position.

Back to projects