This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Commercial cost controls for an NEC3 Option E water project


Client
Joint venture of two main contractors
Service
Advisory
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Confidential
Sector
Water infrastructure

We supported a joint venture delivering a major water treatment upgrade under an amended NEC3 Option E contract. With a planned delivery period of almost five years, the team needed practical controls over expenditure, cost recovery and the records supporting payment. We brought the contractual requirements and the partners’ existing procedures into a common cost-control protocol, supported by weekly reporting.

Background

The project combined substantial direct labour and plant expenditure with specialist subcontract packages. Costs and records came from different teams and systems, while the joint venture also had to meet its water-sector client’s reporting and audit requirements.

A cost reimbursable arrangement still required the team to demonstrate how expenditure met the agreed cost rules. Incomplete allocation records, unexplained differences between systems or poorly supported procurement decisions could expose recovery and margin to challenge. The task was to turn those obligations into controls that the delivery team could use throughout the project.

Our approach

We reviewed the project order, framework provisions and the joint venture’s working agreement alongside the partners’ existing processes. This established the requirements for cost capture, procurement, payment and audit, including the distinction between directly recoverable costs and items covered by overhead allowances. We identified the need to evidence value for money in both tendered and negotiated procurement, and to account for discounts and rebates when assessing recoverable cost.

We set out a cost breakdown structure linking the accounting records to the contract’s cost components and the project’s reporting requirements. The protocol recorded the tender scope, programme and pricing baseline. For civils, construction budgets distinguished specialist subcontract packages from work intended for direct delivery, with separate allowances for labour, plant and materials. This gave the team a basis for understanding subsequent movements in cost.

The weekly civils dashboard compared tender assumptions, current forecasts and actual performance. Labour controls compared allocation sheets with recorded hours and provided for checks against payroll, alongside measures of rates, resource levels and output per shift. Plant controls compared site allocations with hire records and the applicable charging basis, helping the team identify discrepancies and question whether equipment remained necessary.

Materials controls addressed both cost and the quality of supporting records. The protocol specified checks for missing delivery documentation, remaining purchase-order quantities and differences between planned and recorded usage. A weekly cycle of commercial preparation and operational review gave the team a regular opportunity to investigate discrepancies and escalate matters requiring support.

The dashboard developed as the team used it. Shared resources were separated from individual work areas so that their allocation did not distort the apparent concentration of effort. Weekly circulation emails also drew attention to concrete usage missing from allocation records and differences in plant charges, making the issues visible while the relevant site information was still available.

We also documented the monthly payment process, from ledger extraction and cost classification through accruals, review of potentially disallowed costs and supporting submissions. For specialist mechanical and electrical procurement, the protocol set out how package allowances should be tracked through design development and buying decisions. Our handover identified the areas needing continued development and gave the incoming commercial lead a common reference for the work.

Outcome

We issued a cost-control protocol with supporting records. The weekly dashboard was already being circulated to the commercial and delivery teams. The controls brought specific gaps in cost records and charging into operational discussions, with a process for investigating them.

The work connected day-to-day site records with forecasting, payment and audit requirements. It gave the team a clearer basis for explaining expenditure and addressing cost-recovery risks as they emerged. The client’s Commercial Director said the procedures meant the team was “actively managing the cost and mitigating disallowed costs”.

Back to projects