This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Organising a four-week response to a £5 million damages claim


Client
MEP contractor
Service
Claims
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Approx. £12m MEP subcontract
Sector
Building services

We supported an MEP contractor responding to a main contractor’s damages claim of approximately £5 million, with around £3 million said to be withheld from payment. The underlying MEP subcontract was worth approximately £12 million. We organised the commercial, factual, planning and legal inputs into a coordinated response delivered within four weeks of the claim being received.

Background

The claim presented an immediate financial exposure that had not been reflected in the client’s business expectations. It required a detailed answer, while the leadership team also needed to understand how that response would be prepared and what decisions or resources it required.

The material covered several disciplines. Contractual arguments, delay allegations, the factual history and the calculation of damages needed to work together without leaving gaps between separate submissions.

Our approach

We carried out an initial appraisal of the documentation and divided the response into defined workstreams. The plan identified the lead and supporting personnel for the covering and head submissions, legal response, delay analysis, damages assessment and factual account.

The responsibilities were tied to a dated programme. Early actions included a factual-response framework, a planning brief and targeted questions, followed by a kick-off meeting and workshops. Drafting, review and final consolidation then had their own milestones.

That structure made the work accessible to the leadership team. The plan explained what each person needed to contribute and how that information would be used, allowing senior stakeholders to support the response rather than simply wait for a finished document.

We worked with the client’s delivery team to assemble the factual account, and coordinated that record with the planning and legal inputs. Structured workshops were used to examine the claim and resolve information requirements, rather than relying on disconnected requests for documents.

The damages work was considered alongside the alleged breaches and delays. This allowed the commercial response to address the calculation being advanced within the wider explanation of responsibility and cause, while the legal and delay specialists developed their respective sections.

We then brought the workstreams into a coherent submission. The response needed to explain the client’s position as a whole, with the supporting reports available for the main contractor to examine in detail.

The working timetable allowed for review before submission. A defined sequence of first drafts, team feedback and final consolidation helped the team deliver a substantial response within a short period without losing sight of the interfaces between the disciplines.

Outcome

The coordinated response was submitted within four weeks of receipt of the claim. The established client record reports increased confidence among executive stakeholders and a clearer basis for negotiations with the main contractor.

Our contribution was to give a high-pressure claims response direction, ownership and structure, enabling the client to engage with a significant financial exposure through a documented and professionally supported position.

Back to projects