
Connecting water-mains productivity losses with specific changes
- Client
- Civil-engineering contractor
- Service
- Claims
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Approx. £1.6m claim submitted
- Sector
- Water infrastructure
We supported a civil-engineering contractor investigating unrecovered costs across two water-mains renewal contracts at three locations. The planned works covered around 13 kilometres of mains. We connected cost and operational records with the events affecting delivery, developing a substantiated claim of approximately £1.6 million rather than relying on the overall difference between expenditure and revenue.
Background
The original scope combined open-cut excavation, directional drilling and slip-lining. As site information developed, the contractor encountered repeated changes in method and working sequence, alongside permit and access constraints.
The commercial challenge was to explain why those events had generated costs beyond the rates paid for completed work. A higher total labour cost did not, by itself, establish the cause or the amount recoverable under the contracts.
Our approach
We first tested the relationship between the cost position and the timing of the events. Structured analysis connected the labour cost incurred and the hours recovered through measured work with the operational history. This gave the client a basis for deciding whether a more detailed recovery exercise was justified.
We then worked through the records with the operational and commercial teams. Workshops helped locate information that had been kept in different forms, bringing the working sequence, weekly measures and commercial history into a more coherent event record.
The design-change schedule identified 43 changes of installation method, recording the location, relevant weekly measure and year. Many involved moving from directional drilling to open cut. We distinguished the amount already paid for the changed measured work from the additional effect of changing method during delivery.
That additional effect was built up through the activities and resources involved: off-hiring drilling equipment, arranging alternative plant and labour, revising traffic-management arrangements and retaining resources while the new work was organised. Typical event build-ups used contract rates where available and actual cost rates where necessary.
Permit issues were examined separately. Longer or altered works could outlast the available permit, requiring the team to demobilise and move to another location where work could continue. The valuation addressed the associated handling, traffic-management and supervisory input, rather than treating all lost productivity as one undifferentiated delay.
The review also considered restricted access, additional planning and liaison, time-related preliminaries and the effect of carrying work into a later pricing period. Existing change notices were reconciled so that the further amounts being sought could be distinguished from routine measured-work discussions.
Following discussions between the parties, we repackaged the claim into a separate report dealing with these additional effects. Each theme addressed entitlement, cause, operational effect and valuation, with appendices supporting the design changes and pricing.
Outcome
The revised report presented an approximately £1.6 million claim supported by defined change themes and contemporaneous records. It gave the client a basis for issue-by-issue commercial discussions with a strategically important customer.
Our contribution was to move the account beyond a general assertion of poor productivity, explaining how particular changes affected the work and how the associated costs had been assessed.
Back to projects