
Rebuilding a water infrastructure time and cost claim
- Client
- Water infrastructure contractor
- Service
- Claims
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Approx. £1.1m target-cost adjustment sought
- Sector
- Water infrastructure
We supported a water infrastructure contractor seeking agreement of further time entitlement and prolongation costs after extensive design change. The project record included more than 150 variations and 300 project manager instructions. We reconstructed the principal delay events, integrated an independent specialist’s programme analysis, and prepared a detailed submission seeking approximately £1.1 million in target cost adjustments.
Background
An earlier submission had not resolved the later time and cost position. Several people with first-hand knowledge of the project had left, and the remaining team faced a substantial correspondence record. The client needed a coherent explanation of what had changed, who held the relevant design responsibilities and how those changes affected the critical works.
The principal issues concerned revised internal-wall and resilience designs, followed by changes to shaft topping slabs and waterproofing. These activities controlled access for mechanical and electrical installation. Their effect had to be understood alongside other events affecting the same sequence.
Our approach
We held structured discussions with the client’s commercial and operational teams and worked through the CEMAR record of notices, variations, instructions and responses. The aim was to rebuild a chronology that could be followed from the original design obligations through to the information and instructions needed for construction.
The report treated entitlement, cause and effect as connected parts of the same account. For the internal-wall works, it traced the developing design and the instruction process, then explained the dependency between completing the civil work and starting the critical mechanical installation.
For the topping slabs, we followed the design revisions, quotation, formal instruction and confirmation of waterproofing requirements. The analysis distinguished the period waiting for necessary information from procurement and installation activities. It also addressed the relationship with other events affecting progress, keeping potential concurrent periods visible rather than treating every day of overrun as the same type of entitlement.
The client had separately commissioned a delay expert, whose as-planned versus as-built windows analysis established the programme framework. We integrated the relevant findings into the contractual narrative and valuation. This connected the assessed critical periods to the events relied on in the claim without duplicating the specialist’s role.
The prolongation valuation was built from the project’s actual transactions, timesheet-based staff data and supporting invoices. Internal and external staff were examined against the costs already covered by the management fee. Plant, welfare and accommodation costs were checked for relevance before allocation.
Accepted cost items were grouped into seven headings, including staff, ancillary costs, welfare, equipment, scaffolding and attendant labour. Monthly costs were converted into daily rates and applied to the relevant delay periods. The supporting workbook retained the connection between individual transactions, the cost category and the event assessment.
We then developed a further response to the purchaser’s assessment. This addressed the disputed periods with a document chronology and explained why release of a drawing alone did not remove the practical need for specialist procurement, temporary works and mobilisation.
Outcome
The completed submission sought a further extension of time of approximately 22 months and target cost adjustments of approximately £1.1 million. It combined the contractual case, event narratives, independent delay findings and cost substantiation in one report, with the detailed evidence retained in appendices.
The subsequent response gave the client a focused basis for discussing the remaining differences. The deliverable was a substantiated commercial position that could be assessed and negotiated, with the supporting material organised for any further contractual steps.
Back to projects