
Impartial quantum evidence on loss and expense in adjudication
- Client
- Main contractor
- Service
- Expert Witness
- Location
- Northeast, England
- Value
- Confidential
- Sector
- Retail and leisure
We supported a main contractor with impartial quantum expert evidence in an adjudication concerning payment on a retail and leisure development. Instructed at Reply stage, we assessed four heads of loss and expense, rebuilt the supporting cost analysis and provided a supplementary report responding to further evidence.
Background
The dispute concerned the valuation of an interim payment application. The employer had introduced expert evidence challenging the contractor’s loss and expense, with substantially different assessments of suspension costs, prolongation and additional staff resources.
Our role was confined to quantum. Separate delay experts addressed the programme, while the adjudicator had to determine the compensable period. The valuation therefore needed a clear connection between the relevant delay, the resources affected and the supporting records.
Our approach
We separated the assessment into suspension and remobilisation, the main contractor’s prolongation, subcontractor prolongation and staff thickening. Each required its own evidential basis; an overall cost overrun would not establish what was recoverable under each heading.
For the main contractor’s prolongation, we identified when the critical delay occurred from the separate delay evidence and obtained cost records for that period. We used timesheets to establish each staff member’s monthly allocation and tested the ledger entries to identify time-related expenditure. Costs outside the relevant period and items unrelated to delay were excluded.
The financial records comprised a cost summary and more than 40 transaction extracts. We consolidated these into one ledger, reconciled the summary to the detailed entries and retained the links between them. This made it possible to follow each element of the valuation back to its supporting information.
We prepared both an actual-cost assessment and a valuation using contract rates with the contemporaneous staff allocations. Both parties had previously used contract rates, so presenting the two bases allowed the adjudicator to consider the valuation transparently alongside the effect of any agreement between the parties.
Suspension and remobilisation costs were tested against subcontractor payment certificates and plant invoices. We examined the resources retained during the interruption and the amounts certified, making adjustments where the evidence justified a different figure. For subcontractor prolongation, we distinguished the agreed weekly cost from the disputed duration.
The staff-thickening assessment required a further distinction between a financial shortfall and additional work caused by employer instructions. We examined the resource costs and around 60 change instructions, then assessed the time required to administer those changes. We checked for overlap with prolongation and for costs already recovered through other parts of the account.
When the reliability of the cost-system extracts was challenged, we observed how the contractor retrieved the underlying transactions and exported them. Our supplementary report explained that process, supplied further timesheets and supporting documents, and set out the reconciliation method.
Outcome
The adjudicator assessed the four loss and expense headings, applying the agreed rates over the compensable period it determined.
In considering additional staff resources, the adjudicator recognised our effort to “avoid any overlap of claims with those for prolongation” and described our assessment as “fair and reasonable”. The decision allowed a sum for managing change. These findings recognised a resource-based assessment that linked the work undertaken to the costs claimed.
Back to projects