This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Substantiating delay and cost claims on a phased MEP project


Client
Specialist MEP subcontractor
Service
Claims
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Approx. £19m subcontract
Sector
Higher education

We supported a specialist mechanical and electrical subcontractor preparing its final account on a higher education development. The subcontract, worth approximately £19 million, combined a new building with phased refurbishment works. With numerous sectional completion dates and changing access arrangements, the client needed to explain how individual delays affected its programme and establish the associated loss and expense.

Background

The final account deadline was approaching, but the extension-of-time position was not supported by a consolidated submission. The work involved around 50 sectional completion dates, with installation and commissioning activities dependent on access to different parts of the development.

A revised programme instruction had moved completion dates while also compressing the time available for installation. Further access delays followed, and the refurbishment works had their own constraints. A single account of overall delay would have obscured the different events, periods and contractual positions.

Our approach

We worked with the client’s operational, commercial and planning teams to reconstruct the programme history and organise the evidence. The claim was divided into three parts: the earlier new-build access and programme instruction, subsequent new-build access delays, and a refurbishment section. Each had its own narrative, event records and cost assessment.

We compared contractual access dates and working durations with the successive programmes and the dates when workfaces became available. The earlier new-build review showed that an installation period originally allowed at 68 weeks had been compressed by about three months. This helped distinguish the time the client was seeking from the measures it had taken to work towards the revised dates.

For the later new-build period, the report addressed 16 access events. We traced each through the relevant correspondence and site records, then followed its effect on dependent activities and completion. The analysis considered the changing critical paths through installation, access to plant areas and commissioning, with the client’s planners contributing their knowledge of the programme.

The refurbishment assessment required a separate review of trade interfaces. We examined how incomplete partitions, fitted furniture and ceilings constrained the mechanical and electrical installations. The records and programmes were used together to explain why apparently local access problems could prevent completion of the wider section.

We linked the events to the relevant subcontract provisions and collated the notifications supporting each claim. This gave the submissions a contractual structure as well as a factual chronology, with the basis of the requested time adjustments stated.

For prolongation, we organised monthly cost records into staff, design, general preliminaries and supporting labour. Costs were allocated between new-build and refurbishment activities, then weighted across the relevant event periods to derive daily amounts. The analysis distinguished the period in which access was affected from the extension ultimately sought. Preliminaries already included in variations were identified so that they could be credited.

We also examined overtime and additional supervision separately from prolongation. Planned and revised resource curves were compared with actual hours and earned progress to assess the productivity consequences of changing access and sequencing. The report and supporting schedules made the assumptions behind these calculations visible.

Outcome

We delivered three claim reports with supporting programme and cost evidence for the final account submission. The later new-build claim set out a request for 275 calendar days and approximately £1.8 million in loss and expense, alongside the separate earlier new-build and refurbishment assessments.

The client had a structured basis for negotiating its final account, with the events, contractual reasoning and valuation available for examination. The Commercial Director said “the work they did put us in a stronger commercial position”.

Back to projects