
Rebuilding the evidence behind modular construction claims
- Client
- Modular-building specialist
- Service
- Claims
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Total project value: approximately £25m
- Sector
- Rail infrastructure
We supported a modular-building specialist reviewing disputed compensation events on a major rail development. The issues ranged from design change and deferred access to restrictions affecting the installation and storage of completed modules. We examined entitlement and valuation separately, rebuilding event-specific records so that the client could understand the basis, supporting evidence and commercial significance of each claim.
Our work concerned a claim of approximately £5m within an overall claim of approximately £10m that included elements outside our scope. The total project value was approximately £25m. These figures describe the scale of the work, not amounts recovered.
Background
The account contained a substantial history of quotations, assessments and implemented compensation events. Some matters had been accepted in principle but remained disputed in value; others had been rejected and needed a more precise explanation of the contractual event.
The client required a reliable view of that position before deciding how to pursue the differences. Repeating the original claims would not resolve questions about overlapping costs, the basis of valuation or the evidence needed to support a particular installation constraint.
Our client is one of the UK’s leading offsite modular building specialists and agreed to a subcontract to supply and install semi-permanent offices for a major rail project. There was a substantial difference between the main contractor’s final account assessment and our client’s final account assessment and we were instructed, on the back of previous advice we had given, to prepare information for the purposes of a construction adjudication support case.
Our scope included the nine compensation events we had already reviewed, plus a further thirteen compensation events. We were responsible for the entitlement, delay and quantum aspects of the compensation events. Our client appointed the lawyers, and we worked alongside them to prepare the information and outlined the strengths and the weaknesses of each compensation event for consideration.
Our approach
We brought the events into an overall schedule covering five workstreams. It retained the notification, contractual status, quoted and assessed amounts, implementation position and our valuation. This distinguished an accepted event from agreement with the client’s price and kept existing assessments separate from sums that remained under review.
For the valuation work, we compared the original quotation and contractor assessment line by line. The schedules identified the quantities, periods, allocations and rates behind staff, storage, transport and other costs, with separate comments explaining the basis we considered supportable and the information still required.
Deferred access required close attention to the subcontract’s pricing mechanism. We examined the specified premobilisation allowance before considering additional staff costs, so that the assessment addressed potential overlap rather than simply adding every recorded cost to the claim.
Module storage was assessed against the manufacturing and installation sequence and the contract’s free-storage period. The calculations identified the relevant dates for individual modules. Where the available completion records did not support a date consistently, we recorded the evidence needed to test the calculation rather than treating the schedule as conclusive.
The installation-access work required a different form of substantiation. We reviewed the original notifications and rejection reasons, then examined the subcontract information, lifting plans, drawings and site records to explain the particular constraint and the alternative contractual basis being advanced.
One example concerned the effect of ground-bearing and access restrictions on the planned lifting arrangement. The narrative connected the specified working area with the larger equipment and revised installation method being put forward. Another examined why an alternative storage area was not operationally equivalent to space within the planned lifting zone, including the additional trailer and handling requirements.
We separated those events from a broad allegation of disrupted installation. Issued entitlement documents described the relevant obligation, the evidence of the changed condition and its practical effect. Valuation and remaining information requirements could then be considered against that defined event.
The review also distinguished an assessment grounded in the contractual record from alternative positions being developed for the client’s consideration. This allowed the commercial discussion to address both the potential value and the evidential foundation of the next step.
Our client had a contractual date, connected to completion and final account type provisions, by which it must refer any issues to adjudication or accept the main contractor's position. This was circa two to three months from the date we were instructed, so the priority issue was the preparation of a plan showing information we required, actions we would perform and dates by which information would be available for the lawyers to review.
As part of our plan, we revisited the valuation of the previous compensation events to understand where the differences were and identify how we could improve our client’s submission with further evidence, information or explanation. We worked with the appointed lawyers to explain these issues and take advice on whether the compensation events should be approached using a prospective or retrospective assessment where issues such as risk allowances were in contention between the parties.
A key issue in dispute was entitlement to time, and liability for damages or entitlement to recover additional costs. Our appointed delay analyst used a time slice windows analysis based on the relevant accepted programmes. This was the most suitable method in circumstances where there was a lack of contemporaneous records needed to produce a comprehensive as-built programme.
A key part of our service was to provide our client with regular updates on progress and any blockers we had. This was managed through a series of weekly meetings where we provided a two-page summary report of progress and talked to the client’s Managing Director about any risks or opportunities in their case.
Outcome
The client received detailed valuation schedules, an overall event record and issued entitlement narratives for selected disputed access matters. The work gave it a clearer basis for further discussions and for deciding which issues warranted additional evidence or escalation.
Our contribution was to connect the contract, the physical constraints and the cost calculation at event level, replacing a fragmented claims history with a position that could be examined and explained.
The information we provided gave our client a framework for settlement discussions with the contractor. Our client developed a strong understanding of the strengths and weaknesses in its case so that sensible decisions could be taken. This would inevitably involve compromise, but it was our advice that settlement was in our client’s best interests due to the uncertainty that a third-party adjudication process can present.
Our client ultimately made an agreement with the main contractor, and this allowed our client to draw a line under the project from a financial perspective and avoid the costs and uncertainty that a third-party process would present.
What our client said...
“Quantik enabled us to dispassionately consider our position and ultimately move towards commercial settlement.
They provided competent and considered support given with strong contractual knowledge. The open and honest discussions that the prompted provided us with the ability to dispassionately consider the options.”
CEO
Back to projects