
Commercial pricing review for a specialist framework tender
- Client
- Main contractor
- Service
- Tendering
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Confidential
- Sector
- Defence and regulated engineering
We supported a main contractor preparing a tender for a specialist defence framework. The client needed an external review of its fee and hourly-rate strategy before its internal approval process. We assessed the relationship between the proposed pricing, the evaluation approach and the client’s expected delivery model, preparing a commercial considerations paper within about a week of receiving the pricing information.
Background
The client’s initial proposal used a consistent headline fee across delivery regions. It wanted to understand whether that approach balanced competitiveness with the commercial return needed to deliver specialist work over the framework term.
Fee percentages and people rates were evaluated differently, while the work ultimately secured could differ from the assumptions used at tender. The review therefore needed to connect the evaluated price with the client’s operational capabilities and expected work mix.
Our approach
We reviewed the procurement pricing guidance alongside the client’s rate card and proposed commercial position. This established which elements were being evaluated and how the fee and labour-rate components interacted. The rate-card information also provided context for understanding the cost and recovery assumptions behind the proposed charges.
Short working sessions with the client clarified its likely delivery locations, specialist capability and expectations of the competing market. We recorded those inputs as assumptions, distinguishing information provided by the client from matters that would remain unknown until the tender competition was complete.
We compared four broad approaches, covering the existing national model, alternative relationships between fee and people rates, regional differentiation and a mixed approach. Each option was considered in terms of potential scoring implications, commercial recovery and the credibility of the delivery assumptions supporting it.
The comparison addressed the tension between a competitive evaluated price and sustainable delivery. A lower headline fee could change the way the client expected to recover costs and margin, while different locations and specialist roles could have different commercial requirements. We set out those implications so that each option could be judged in the context of the anticipated work.
We also examined the limitations of the comparison. The competitor population and the spread of other bids were unknown, and specialist work was not fully represented by generic people-rate categories. The paper made those assumptions explicit and treated indicative scoring as a basis for discussion rather than a prediction of the tender result.
The findings were brought together in a commercial considerations paper ahead of the client’s governance review. The paper explained the options, their trade-offs and the assumptions requiring the client’s judgement before submission. It kept the ultimate pricing decision with the client.
Outcome
The client received a structured assessment within a compressed period, enabling its approvers to consider the commercial consequences of alternative pricing strategies before finalising the submission.
The work gave the governance discussion a clearer basis: how the price would be evaluated, how it related to expected delivery, and where uncertainty remained. Client feedback said the advice helped “inform our commercial strategy and underpin internal governance discussions”.
Back to projects