This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. By using the site, you accept our use of cookies.

Clarifying and valuing a remedial scheme for mediation


Client
Property insurer
Service
Expert Witness
Location
United Kingdom
Value
Claimed remedial costs around £600,000
Sector
Residential

We supported an insurer and its solicitors with independent quantum evidence in a residential latent defects dispute. Claimed remedial costs were in the region of £600,000, but the parties’ technical reports did not provide a consistent description of the work to be valued. We developed a structured remedial scope with the insurer’s experts and prepared an itemised valuation for use in mediation.

Background

The owners alleged structural, waterproofing and fire protection defects in their home. Different expert reports, pleadings and cost documents described the issues in different ways, making it difficult to connect the alleged defects with a defined repair and a reliable price.

The insurer needed a valuation of its experts’ proposed remedial scheme. This was a separate task from deciding liability or policy coverage. Before pricing the work, we needed to establish what that particular scheme required and how it related to the issues in the claim.

Our approach

We reviewed the technical reports alongside the letter of claim and the parties’ pleadings. The terminology and structure did not align consistently, so we prepared a Scott Schedule linking the alleged defects to the relevant references and the proposed remedial work. This allowed the technical experts to confirm or clarify our understanding before it became the basis of a valuation.

The schedule distinguished structural and non-structural matters and recorded the opposing positions. It gave the insurer and its advisers a common framework for examining the scope, with the cost build-ups tied to identifiable work items rather than broad descriptions of defects.

We reviewed the cost information already available, including an older contractor quotation and the claimant’s schedule. The amounts differed between documents, and some figures were rounded sums with little explanation of their basis. We considered where the quotation remained relevant, while recognising that its age and the developing scope limited how far it could be relied upon.

The remedial valuation was built from labour, material and equipment resources. Quantities were taken from available information where possible, with assumptions recorded where details were incomplete. Labour rates were informed by price-book data, while supplier prices provided a basis for materials and equipment. The supporting workbook retained the calculations for each item.

We considered the associated work needed to carry out a repair. For example, a local repair at a beam support could involve temporary support, removal and storage of doors, opening up finishes and subsequent reinstatement. Capturing those activities made the valuation more complete than pricing the permanent repair alone.

Access and supervision were assessed against the proposed scope. The scaffolding allowance considered the extent of external work and the uncertainty over its precise locations. Management and supervision were related to the likely repair period and the resource needed, rather than assuming a full-time site team. Overheads, profit and other allowances were identified separately from direct work.

The valuation and Scott Schedule were updated as the remedial scope developed. The retained worksheets allowed individual changes to be followed through to the cost position, including comparison of pricing at different dates.

Outcome

We produced a costed valuation of the insurer’s proposed remedial scheme for use at mediation. It provided a clear account of the work, resources and assumptions supporting that scheme, giving the insurer and its solicitors a reasoned basis for their proposed settlement position.

The value of the assessment lay in making a complex technical dispute easier to examine financially. The instructing solicitor highlighted “the in depth and critical nature of their assessment”.

Back to projects