
Securing time and cost agreement after water infrastructure change
- Client
- Water infrastructure contractor
- Service
- Claims
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Confidential
- Sector
- Water infrastructure
We supported a water infrastructure contractor whose project had passed its contractual completion date while significant changes remained unresolved. The client faced delay damages and the cost of keeping the project running for longer. We developed an event-by-event extension of time and target cost submission, then supported the commercial discussions that led to agreement of the time position and recovery of approximately 80% of the submitted prolongation claim.
Background
The work involved new water-supply infrastructure, including shafts and tunnelling close to existing assets. The initial target cost and approved programme had been agreed against the design and scope available at contract award. Subsequent instructions introduced further monitoring, assessment and protection requirements, affecting when the construction work could proceed.
The client needed to explain why those requirements changed its contractual position, demonstrate their effect on completion and substantiate the associated cost. Under the target cost arrangement, agreement also mattered to the later pain and gain calculation: the commercial assessment needed to reflect changes in the work rather than leave the original target unadjusted.
Our approach
We began with a workshop to understand the project history and establish a recovery plan. The analysis was organised around four principal issues: additional monitoring, development of an impact assessment, consequential delays to shaft tunnelling, and work around existing trunk mains.
For each issue, we traced the original scope, the subsequent instruction and the activities affected. The report linked these records to the contract’s separate grounds for extensions of time and target cost adjustments. It explained why the instructed requirements extended beyond the basis on which the original programme and price had been agreed.
The programme assessment used an updated working programme alongside the contractual baseline. The relevant activities were coded to the four issues, allowing their durations and critical-path relationships to be followed through to the revised completion date. A discrepancy between a programme milestone and the contractual takeover date was expressly accounted for in the method.
The valuation was developed from costs incurred during the periods in which the events affected the work. Staff costs were obtained from monthly reporting, while other site overheads were assessed from the underlying cost information. Specialist tunnelling costs were allocated to the months in which they had been incurred, allowing the event periods and the cost records to be brought together.
The submission set out the entitlement, delay effect and valuation for each issue, supported by a correspondence schedule, programme analysis and cost calculations. When the purchaser challenged the assessment, we prepared comparisons identifying the differences and the contractual basis of the client’s response.
Those comparisons went into the detail of staff rates, hours, applicable cost periods, site overheads and specialist subcontract costs. They helped the parties discuss specific differences rather than negotiate against an unexplained total. We also prepared material for the negotiation meetings and attended discussions with the client.
Outcome
The client agreed a 417-day extension of time, approximately 14 months, covering the relevant delay period and relieving the associated liability for delay damages. The subsequent commercial discussions resulted in recovery of approximately 80% of the submitted prolongation claim.
The work combined detailed substantiation with support through the negotiation itself. It gave the client a coherent explanation of the changes, their programme consequences and their cost, while helping maintain the working relationship between the parties.
Back to projects