
Substantiating delay and prolongation costs on an MEP subcontract
- Client
- Specialist MEP subcontractor
- Service
- Claims
- Location
- United Kingdom
- Value
- Confidential
- Sector
- Healthcare
We supported a specialist mechanical, electrical and public health subcontractor seeking time and cost recovery on a healthcare development. The works had experienced approximately six months of delay. We rebuilt the claim around contractual entitlement, independent delay analysis and the records supporting the costs incurred.
Background
The main contractor had recognised part of the delay and made a partial payment for loss and expense, but the remaining time and cost position was disputed. The subcontractor's existing cost request needed clearer particulars linking the resources claimed to the events affecting its work.
The client wanted to negotiate the final account. It also wanted the submission to be sufficiently detailed to support adjudication if commercial discussions did not resolve the dispute. Our task was to prepare a coherent account of entitlement and valuation from the available contract, programme and cost information.
Our approach
We separated the work into the substantiation of costs for delay already recognised and the assessment of further time and money being sought. The client's independent delay expert had used a time slice windows analysis to identify critical delay events and the periods when their effects were felt. We used that analysis as the basis for the claim and identified the subcontract provisions supporting an extension of time and loss and expense for each event.
The event narratives brought together the relevant instructions, access restrictions, progress records and photographs. For example, incomplete partitions affected the release of areas for MEP installation, while restricted access to roof plant and later instructed works affected other periods. We linked each event to its supporting records and relevant cost period, excluding delay identified as non-claimable.
We reconstructed the valuation from five cost extracts covering the client's accounting systems and design time records. Staff and other expenditure were organised by person, description and cost code on a monthly basis. We removed duplicates, costs that could not be shown to relate to the project and items that were not time related.
For staff, we examined the roles and allocations alongside the Contract Sum Analysis and site attendance information. This enabled the submission to explain the resources being claimed and address the main contractor's concern that the claim represented additional staffing rather than prolongation. Monthly costs were converted into daily rates and applied to the relevant event dates, preserving changes in expenditure as the project progressed.
Design time was filtered to the meetings falling within the delay periods. Plant and other site costs were reviewed by activity and cost category, with checks on items potentially covered by variations. We also distinguished agreed subcontractor costs from outstanding liabilities, retaining the supporting final-account or claim records for each.
The report brought these strands together event by event: the contractual basis, the delay analysis, the contemporaneous evidence and the valuation. Payment applications and notices were reviewed separately to establish the amounts already assessed and to support the interest calculation. The resulting schedules showed how each component of the claim had been derived.
Outcome
We prepared a claim report setting out a revised claim assessment including resource costs, identified subcontractor liabilities and interest. This was lower than the client's earlier request, with a clearer explanation of what was being claimed and the evidence supporting it.
The client submitted the report to the main contractor with the independent delay analysis and supporting valuation records. It had a documented basis for negotiating the final account and for considering further contractual steps if needed, with the time, entitlement and cost arguments presented together.
Back to projects